Brooks: “My analysis begins with a remarkable essay that Jonathan Rauch wrote for National Affairs in 2018 called “The Constitution of Knowledge.”
https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-constitution-of-knowledge
Some excerpts from Rauch:
On any given day, of course, we won’t all agree on what has or has not checked out. The speed of light is widely agreed upon, but many propositions are disputed, and in some cases, such as man-made climate change, there is even a dispute about whether the proposition is in dispute. The community that lives by the standards of verification constantly argues about itself, yet by doing so provides its members with time and space to work through their disagreements without authoritarian oversight.
The results have been spectacular, in three ways above all. First, by organizing millions of minds to tackle billions of problems, the epistemic constitution disseminates knowledge at a staggering rate. Every day, probably before breakfast, it adds more to the canon of knowledge than was accumulated in the 200,000 years of human history prior to Galileo’s time.
Second, by insisting on validating truths through a decentralized, non-coercive process that forces us to convince each other with evidence and argument, it ends the practice of killing ideas by killing their proponents. What is often called the marketplace of ideas would be more accurately described as a marketplace of persuasion, because the only way to establish knowledge is to convince others you are right.
Third, by placing reality under the control of no one in particular, it dethrones intellectual authoritarianism and commits liberal society foundationally to intellectual pluralism and freedom of thought.
Together, these innovations have done nothing less than transform our way of living, learning, and relating to one another. But they have always had natural enemies. One, an ancient parasite, has recently mutated into something like an epistemic super-virus.
November 2024 M T W T F S S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Subscribe to Blog via Email
Join 183 other subscribersQuote of the Day
more QuotesCategories
- Addiction (14)
- Advance Directives (11)
- Adventures (5)
- Advocacy (221)
- Aging Sites (148)
- Animals (145)
- Architecture (14)
- Art (136)
- artificial intelligence (1)
- Books (72)
- Business (111)
- Caregiving (16)
- CCRC Info (40)
- Civic Engagement Group (118)
- Climate (49)
- Communication (24)
- Community Engagement Group (6)
- Cooking (14)
- Crime (47)
- Dance (46)
- Dementia (85)
- Disabilities (17)
- drugs (3)
- Economics (25)
- Education (147)
- end of life (112)
- energy (2)
- Entertainment (94)
- environment (287)
- Essays (342)
- Ethics (5)
- Finance (60)
- Fitness (32)
- Food (58)
- Gardening (20)
- Gay rights/essays (1)
- Government (260)
- Grief (26)
- Guns (34)
- happiness (114)
- Health (744)
- History (292)
- Holidays (65)
- Homeless (23)
- Hospice (6)
- Housing (4)
- Humor (991)
- Immigration (3)
- In the Neighborhood (437)
- Justice (35)
- Kindness (13)
- language (3)
- Law (102)
- literature (20)
- Love (1)
- Media (37)
- Memory Loss (3)
- Mental Health (10)
- Military (25)
- Morality (6)
- Movies (13)
- Music (185)
- Nature (172)
- nutrition (1)
- Obituaries (13)
- On Stage (7)
- Opera (22)
- Organ donation (1)
- Parks (30)
- Pets (14)
- Philanthropy (17)
- Philosophy (19)
- Photography (95)
- Plants (2)
- Poetry (35)
- Politics (541)
- Poverty (13)
- prayer (8)
- Race (84)
- Recipes (1)
- Recycling (1)
- refugees (1)
- Religion (68)
- Remembrances (59)
- Retirement (15)
- Safety (58)
- Satire (43)
- Scams (32)
- Science and Technology (202)
- Shopping (9)
- Singing (1)
- Skyline Info (45)
- sleep (8)
- Social justice (170)
- Space (3)
- Spiritual (16)
- Sport (13)
- Sports (49)
- Taxes (5)
- technology (12)
- terrorism (1)
- theater (12)
- Traffic (14)
- Transportation (71)
- Travel (32)
- Uncategorized (1,252)
- Volunteering (16)
- Voting (3)
- WACCRA (7)
- War (73)
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Join 183 other subscribers