Ed note: Would love to hear your comments!
From Slate: In a three-minute digital short titled “Sister,” Mulaney and others stage a mock pharmaceutical ad for a product to help care for your elderly parents. To the camera, Mulaney says that he loves his aging father who needs care, but he “didn’t want to put him in a nursing home,” and “a private health aide could cost thousands a week.” The solution? Sister, “a live-in, 24/7 eldercare provider that is completely free, and also your sister.” Andrew Dismukes then comes in and states that he doesn’t want to help his aging mother in the bathroom, and “Sister doesn’t either, but she will, whereas I won’t.” Getting the service is easy, Mulaney jokes: “Simply text ‘dad fell’ to Sister and she will quit her job, break her lease, and move halfway across the country to take care of him.” The service works due to “years of internalized sexism” that “warped Sister’s brain into thinking caretaking is her responsibility, and somehow not yours.” Kenan Thompson also explains how it comes at no cost or harm to the men of the family and their financial prospects: “Since your parents’ will predates their dementia, using Sister won’t change your inheritance. You’ll still get 50 percent of the house she’s currently deep-cleaning.”
The skit (apparently written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell, surprisingly two men) is pitch-perfect down to each detail. At one point, Mulaney says that not only will she talk to insurance companies and other players in adult care over the phone, but she will be “talked to by Dad,” before it cuts to their father making a comment about her weight. Mulaney also comments that Sister helped him get closer to his father by giving them “something to bond over” during his “infrequent visits.” That thing is, of course, criticizing Sister.
To so specifically poke fun at an accepted gender dynamic of life that we all know to be true, but do not interrogate enough societally, is brutal and entertaining in equal measure. (This remains true even if it does not necessarily apply in every single case: A discussion on Slate Slack revealed that, occasionally, Sister is Brother.) As the eldest child and a Sister myself, I have often found myself bracing for this future reality, one that has also been brought to light in movies like American Fiction. But the existence of “Sister” as a three-minute pill on SNL also proves that the weaponized incompetence of men is just that. Men—or, at least Day and Seidell—are noticing this dynamic, and the fact that we all laugh at it as hard as we do, in the incredulous way that many of us likely responded to the skit, shows that many of the rest of us have noticed it too. Whether any of these brothers care enough to change it may be a different story.